Best pet shops in New York
The 10 places with the best Google ratings, weighed by how many people rated them. Under each: what customers praise most, from our summary of recent reviews.
- 1
Wagwear
4.7(917 · Google)Manhattan+1 888-924-9327What customers praise: Effective paw protection with WagWellies
Dog parents enthusiastically praise the WagWellies line of dog boots for their reliable fit and durability. Reviewers note the shoes stay securely on paws during walks, effectively protecting pads from scorching summer sidewalks, winter snow, and rough terrain. Owners of senior pets also report significant mobility help for paw-dragging injuries.
Some mention: Helpful custom fittings despite desk friction
from 64 recent reviews
- 2
Pet Delight
4.7(514 · Google)Brooklyn+1 718-788-7970What customers praise: Reliable nutrition and supplies for pets
Pet parents highlight the store as a dependable destination for canine nutrition and specialized companion care products. Reviewers mention traveling across boroughs specifically to purchase tailored formulations, such as kangaroo meat diet for dogs.
Some mention: Vast inventory with mixed store atmosphere
from 7 recent reviews
- 3
Unleashed by Petco
4.5(839 · Google)Brooklyn+1 718-230-5059What customers praise: Helpful retail associates and attentive cashiers
Shoppers consistently praise the store associates on Seventh Avenue for their warm greetings, product guidance, and cheerful demeanor. Employees like Lily receive frequent personal mentions for outstanding assistance. A couple of patrons noted occasional friction at checkout, but overall customer service remains a highlight.
from 69 recent reviews
- 4
Crosby Pet Center Inc
4.4(336 · Google)The Bronx+1 718-822-6900What customers praise: Helpful and knowledgeable floor staff
Shoppers consistently praise the retail team for their friendly demeanor, attentive customer service, and practical guidance on pet nutrition and care. Long-time customers appreciate employees taking time to answer product questions without rushing. While one reviewer criticized an interaction with management, the vast majority commend the floor team for creating a welcoming neighborhood vibe.
Some mention: Affordable grooming alongside retail markups
from 14 recent reviews
- 5
The Pet Store
4.4(359 · Google)Manhattan+1 646-998-4707What customers praise: Helpful and welcoming neighborhood staff
Shoppers consistently praise the staff at this East Harlem store for being welcoming, courteous, and attentive. Multiple reviewers mention employees going out of their way to carry heavy supplies or source emergency aquariums on short notice. A single customer reported feeling dismissed after asking about merchandise rates.
Some mention: Fair rates with occasional disputes
from 16 recent reviews
- 6
Zoo-Rama Pet Shop
4.4(497 · Google)The Bronx+1 718-430-0909What customers praise: Warm and supportive shop personnel
Clients speak very fondly of the store owners and customer service staff, noting their helpful guidance, knowledge of pet care, and warm demeanor. Many customers recount positive memories of staff guiding them through pet adoptions and offering continuous post-purchase advice. Reviewers also appreciate smooth, friendly assistance with dog licensing and pet supplies.
Some mention: Happy pet stories with welfare note
from 17 recent reviews
- 7
Brooklyn Zoo & Aquarium Pet Store
4.4(642 · Google)Brooklyn+1 718-251-7389What customers praise: Friendly and welcoming neighborhood ownership
Visitors highlight the warm personal greeting from the owner and staff members, describing them as exceptionally kind, patient, and eager to assist. Shoppers appreciate the helpful guidance when selecting companion animals or picking out appropriate specialty supplies in Mill Basin.
from 16 recent reviews
- 8
Cross Bronx Pet Shop
4.4(793 · Google)The Bronx+1 718-597-5652What customers praise: Helpful and welcoming store associates
Visitors highlight the warm and attentive customer service provided by retail staff and groomers. Employees are described as kind, accommodating, and eager to assist when guiding shoppers through pet food options or checking in animals for grooming services.
Some mention: Neighborhood supply selection and inventory limits
from 5 recent reviews
- 9
Pet Resources
4.4(1,000 · Google)The Bronx+1 718-842-4141What customers praise: Attentive and knowledgeable store staff
Local pet owners praise the friendly and welcoming attitude of the store personnel and management. Reviewers appreciate the staff willingness to share practical pet care advice, guide first-time puppy owners, and answer detailed questions about reptile supplies. The family-owned neighborhood atmosphere is repeatedly highlighted by loyal customers.
Some mention: Extensive inventory with return limitations
from 15 recent reviews
- 10
PetSmart
4.4(1,710 · Google)Staten Island+1 929-308-2634What customers praise: Helpful associates alongside management issues
Customers frequently praise retail staff members such as Marco and Andrew for their deep product knowledge and friendly assistance with specialized diets. Many shoppers feel well-supported when selecting pet nutrition. However, a number of patrons report inflexible and discourteous treatment from store managers during salon check-in.
Some mention: Mixed feedback on salon animal care
from 41 recent reviews
How we ranked
By Google rating, weighed by the number of ratings: a 4.9 from 15 people ranks below a 4.8 from 400. Only places with at least 10 ratings. Ratings checked 7 Oct 2026. No place pays to be on this list.


